Is Your Compensation Plan Living in the Past?
For most employees, compensation evolves over time. Salaries and hourly wages typically increase through a combination of market adjustments and merit, giving managers a natural opportunity to discuss performance, development, and future potential. Freight brokerage often operates differently. Many firms keep salaries as low as possible, avoid raises, and rely almost entirely on production-based incentives. That approach may feel efficient, but it overlooks one of compensation’s most useful motivational tools.
Incentive compensation and salary increases should reward different things. A commission plan is designed to pay for measurable results already delivered, such as gross margin, load volume, or margin percentage. Those metrics matter, but if they already drive incentive pay, they should not also dominate the annual raise decision. Paying twice for the same results only amplifies one message while ignoring other behaviors that determine whether a company can grow sustainably.
A well-designed performance review should examine the contributions the incentive plan does not capture. Does the employee complete paperwork accurately and on time? Are attendance and punctuality reliable? How does the employee treat coworkers and customers? Are they expanding their industry knowledge, strengthening their skills, and preparing for greater responsibility? Even top producers may have weaknesses in these areas, and addressing them can improve customer loyalty, staff continuity, legal risk, and long-term enterprise value.
The most important distinction is timing. Incentives reward the past: the employee produced a result, and the company paid for it. A salary increase rewards the future. It signals that the company expects the employee to create more value over time and is willing to invest in that potential. Curiosity, adaptability, professional development, and the ability to use new technology effectively will become increasingly valuable as traditional brokerage work changes.
That means raise decisions should focus on evidence of future value. Look for employees who seek education, learn from mentors, improve processes, embrace useful technology, and demonstrate the judgment needed for broader roles. These qualities may not immediately appear in a production report, but they often separate employees who merely repeat last year’s performance from those who help build next year’s business.
There is one common compensation trap to avoid. If a commission threshold, draw, or seat cost automatically rises whenever an employee receives a salary increase, the raise can feel like a punishment. The employee sees more salary on one line of the paycheck and less commission on another. Instead, base the production threshold on the midpoint for the role rather than each person’s exact salary. This keeps the incentive plan focused on production while allowing salary growth to recognize development and future contribution.
The bottom line is simple: commissions recognize what employees have already accomplished; salary increases encourage what they can become. Freight brokers that use both tools intentionally can reward strong production without neglecting the behaviors, skills, and leadership capacity required for lasting success. If your company never increases salaries, ask what message employees receive about improving their future value—and why they should make that investment if the company will not.