Tech in Logistics: What Questions Are We Answering?
Content for this blog came from TIA’s Freight Beat Podcast episode What Does All This Freight Tech Actually Solve?
The freight technology ecosystem is on fire with momentum. Investors who once kept their distance are writing checks, brokerages once burned by software built by people who didn’t know a flatbed from a flathead screwdriver are investing in new tools, and at every conference floor is the chatter is around the latest innovation in artificial intelligence.
Some of that is real progress. Some of it is fear of missing out, of worrying that there’s something better out there. For 3PLs and freight brokers, the hard discipline is not choosing a tool. It is choosing the question the tool is supposed to answer.
Start with the problem, not the product
The standard advice to a skeptical brokerage is “just give it a try.” That is an oversimplification. Eric Williams, CEO and co-founder of Beagl, puts it plainly: “I don’t think you just try some of these things. What you do try needs to actually solve a problem that you know you have.”
Successful deployments begin with an understanding of your issue, and a clear end goal. From there, you can work backward and set milestones and success metrics, and hold your team accountable to them. Before you evaluate any vendor, run every pain point through one filter: “Is this a people problem? Is it a process problem? Or is it a lack of technology problem?” Only the last one is solved by software alone.
Technology will force process change
Even the right tool will not slot neatly into decades of habit. “New technology often is going to require process change,” Williams notes. “That’s not something the technology can fix for you. That’s a business problem that requires leadership to buy in and actually solve.”
If leadership is not committed to trying new things, any tech implementation should start with people, not platforms. The time and energy a rollout demands are an investment in their own right, and they deserve the same scrutiny as the contract price. Your leadership should know that the result will pay off in some way, and it’s worht their time and effort. Executing on a plan means you’ve already executed on planning.
Price the lanes you can actually serve
RFPs show the gap clearly. Every shipper tells brokers not to price lanes they cannot service, yet many brokerages bid everything anyway. Shippers end up with 20 or 30 providers stacked within 5 to 10% of each other on a lane, with no view of the capacity behind each number.
The better use of technology here is not faster bid submission. It is segmentation: tiering lanes by risk, mapping your network against the customer’s, and closing coverage gaps before you commit a rate. As Williams describes the industry today, “We move very fast upstream and then we figure it out downstream. We’re actually backwards in the way that we work.”
Know what AI will and won’t touch
AI is already absorbing low-value but necessary work like track and trace. It is moving into prescriptive analytics that tell brokers which tasks deserve attention, and how to complete them. Brokers are exceptional problem solvers; prioritization is where software can help most.
What AI will not touch, in Williams’s words, is “the relationships. Period.” A voice bot designed to pass as human does not build trust, this is where the real brokers will flourish. The real payoff is the hours handed back to understand customer pain points, solve them, and earn the next call.
Watch for red flags on both sides
External red flags are familiar: vague integration and deployment timelines, no success stories from operations like yours, and vendors unwilling to offer a free demo. “If they’re not willing to give you a try before you buy,” Williams says, “that means they probably don’t have any confidence in the solution themselves.”
Internal red flags matter just as much. If you cannot state your own problem and your willingness to change, you will not know what to ask a vendor. Leadership teams should surface these issues in their weekly meetings, confirm them with the floor, and then decide whether technology is the answer at all.
The bottom line
The brokerages that win the next decade will not be the ones that adopted the most technology. They will be the ones that asked the sharpest questions first, and built their tools around the answers.